Fundamentals of Statistics contains material of various lectures and courses of H. Lohninger on statistics, data analysis and chemometrics......click here for more.

Types of Error

In general, there are two different types of error that can occur when making a decision: the first kind ("type 1 errors") are those errors which occur when we reject the null hypothesis although the null hypothesis is true. The second kind ("type 2 errors") of errors arise when we accept the null hypothesis although the alternative hypothesis is true.

An example should clarify the situation. Suppose you want to buy ore to produce iron. You decide that the ore has to have a certain minimum concentration of iron to be useful for the process. Since the concentration of iron varies for each delivery, you have to ensure that, on average, you receive more than the specified minimum concentration. In order to be cautious you don't trust your suppliers, assuming they can't fulfill your requirements (H0, or null hypothesis). You will believe them only if they can supply evidence that the reqirements are met (H1, or alternative hypothesis).

You formulate your hypotheses:
H0:  iron concentration is less or equal to the specified limit
H1:  concencration is higher the limit

Due to the uncertainties involved in the process of determining the iron content, there is a risk that your decision is wrong. When you decide to buy a particular batch of the ore, and it turns out that the specifications are not met, you have made a type I error (i.e. rejecting H0 when it is true). There is also the possibility that we accept H0, although it is in fact wrong: we don't buy although the specification is met. That is called type 2 error.

Since our decision can be false or true, and the null hypothesis can also be false or true, there are four possible outcomes of a test. The probabilities for a type 1 error and type 2 error are usually denoted by α and β, respectively.

Which of the errors is more serious, depends on the damage that is related to it. Type 1 and type 2 errors are related to each other. Increasing the type 1 error decreases the type 2 error and vice versa.

In the case given above a type II error does not harm us, except one of the rejected bidders offers a much lower price. But we are concerned about making a type I error, it would mean we would buy the ore without getting the required content of iron. A more elaborate description about type I and type II errors can be found in the following interacte example:


 



NOTES

  • α is the failure rate of the test procedure, not that of a particular test result, and
  • 1-α is the confidence in the test procedure.
  • Rejecting a hypothesis is stronger, than accepting a hypothesis, so we reject H0 with an error probability of α or there is not sufficient evidence for the rejection of H0, but we do not accept H0 unless β is known.
  • 1-β is called the power of a test

Last Update: 2012-10-08